Peck & Peck Audiobook Review: Delightful and Disappointing in Turns
Bonnie Garmus builds an enchanting world of poetry and publishing, then spends too many hours on the villain rather than the good guys.
My Rating: ★★★☆☆ (3/5 stars: Disappointing)
- Author: Bonnie Garmus
- Category: Literary Fiction
- Published: 2026
- Runtime: 18 hours
Do you find the cover of Peck & Peck as captivating as I do? It shows the best of the book: a mythical poetry publishing house in 1980s New York, with one of the story’s quirky characters in each window. But those high points are overshadowed by a relentless villain and a good-versus-evil story that runs on too long. I enjoyed Garmus’s Lessons in Chemistry and wanted badly to adore this new tale of an ordinary person turned hero, but it just didn’t click for me.
Batter Gray has loved poetry since he was 11. He doesn’t especially want to write it; he just loves reading it. After years of being told poetry is a terrible career choice, he drifts through retail and restaurant jobs until he stumbles onto an opening at Peck & Peck, a hallowed poetry journal.
The extraordinary Peck & Peck building is my favorite part of the book. Batter follows a stranger’s block-by-block directions until he nearly gives up, then finds the building at twilight: triangular, with rounded corners and a topiary in each window. Inside are den-like offices, a conference table with no right angles, and sculptural trees preserved on the top floor.
The characters are the other standout. Batter’s mother, a typeface expert who knows what every font means and tells improbable stories about the heroic dog Batter was named after, is a delight. Peck & Peck employs 39 editors, several of whom become Batter’s friends. Then there’s the mysterious Declonius Peck, who appears in Batter’s basement office once in a while, cocktail in hand at 8 in the morning, with tempting and yet frustrating invitations.
But one character looms over the rest: the villain, Salton Peck. As head of a poetry journal, he can’t stand poetry. As leader of a team, he can’t stand people. As owner of an architectural marvel, he wears ill-fitting cargo shorts. He’s crafted as the most villainous of bosses, to the point of comic absurdity. For many readers, he’s just that: a humorous farce. For me, he grated.
My other disappointment with the book is the length. At 18 hours, this runs about one-and-a-half times as long as a typical novel. Especially with so much time spent on the villain, plus a long-running family feud, I felt like a few hours could have been edited out.
Like Lessons in Chemistry, this book is vivid and inventive, with so much to appreciate. There’s an art-versus-commerce question at the heart of the book that has so much potential, along with the delightful setting and wonderfully quirky characters. I just wish that it could be rebalanced toward showing the wonder of poetry and unexpected heroes a little more, and the frustrations and foibles of life a little less.
Peck & Peck is available on Audible and Libro.fm as an audiobook, or in hardcover. (affiliate links)
The Audiobook Experience
★★★☆☆
Seth Numrich narrates with very good craft. In fact, he performs the characters’ voices so effectively, including a lot of dialogue and shouting from the evil Salton that I found the audio hard to listen to.
Multitasking potential is typical for fiction.
Audio or print? Audio helps you power through the middle, but if strongly acted-out villain voices wear on you, choose print.
Read It or Skip It?
Read it if: you love publishing and architecture as a backdrop, enjoy stories about everyday people as quiet heroes, enjoy good-versus-evil satire, or want the latest literary fiction.
Skip it if: you need to connect with the main character, or black-and-white stories bother you.
If you’re on the fence, skip it.
Related: Lessons in Chemistry by the same author. The Lions of Fifth Avenue by Fiona Davis for another story set inside a beloved New York institution. Yellowface by R.F. Kuang for a fantastic story about another bad workplace situation in publishing, with a very different mood and dark humor.
Book Club Guide
As a big new literary fiction release, Peck & Peck will be a popular book club pick, and there’s a lot to unpack in terms of both the story and characters and the author’s craft.
- What do you think Garmus was trying to say about art versus commerce? Did the story’s exploration of that feel authentic or heavy-handed?
- How did you feel about the evil editor-in-chief, Salton? Was he believable, or overdone?
- Did you relate to Batter? Did you find him likable, and did he work for you as a normal-guy main character?
- Batter loves poetry and wants a career in it, yet never really tries to write poems. What did you make of that choice?
- Which supporting characters stood out to you: the other editors, Andy, Batter’s mother, or someone else? Why?
- What did you think of the ending? Were you surprised by the resolution of the mystery, or did you see it coming?
Listen Now
I only recommend audiobooks and resources I’ve personally experienced. This post contains affiliate links — if you purchase through them, I earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
- 🎧 Audible — Start Peck & Peck free with Audible’s trial
- 🎧 Libro.fm — Listen and support indie bookstores simultaneously
- 📖 Hardcover — The physical companion for your shelf
FAQ
Is Peck & Peck worth reading?
It depends on what you read for. It’s well crafted, with an enchanting setting and fun supporting characters, but at nearly 18 hours it drags a bit, and its good versus evil story is heavy-handed. If you love the publishing world as a backdrop, give it a try. If you’re on the fence, skip it.
Is Peck & Peck better on audio or in print?
It’s a close call. The audio narration by Seth Numrich is well done, but he acts out the voices strongly, and the villainous editor-in-chief can be tiring to listen to. If strongly acted voices bother you, choose print.
Who narrates the Peck & Peck audiobook?
Seth Numrich narrates. He’s a good narrator who shows range by acting a number of different characters here.
How long is the Peck & Peck audiobook?
Almost 18 hours, making it a few hours longer than a typical novel.
Is Peck & Peck like Lessons in Chemistry?
The characters and stories are very different, but the author’s cerebral approach and thoughtful craft come through in both, along with her love of showing an ordinary person become a hero at the center of a remarkable story.